04/09/2015 03:16 pm ET Updated Apr 09, 2015

Frank Rich: NBC's Marketing Of Brian Williams Made His Fiasco 'Probably Irreparable'

Frank Rich isn't optimistic that NBC will be able to welcome Brian Williams back to the network at the end of his six-month suspension because of the way they've marketed the anchor, he explained in a HuffPost Live interview on Thursday.

"They promoted [Williams] relentlessly as the guy who goes there, who's this fighter for the news and goes to dangerous zones and it creates this image," the New York Magazine columnist told host Josh Zepps. He likened the situation to "The Wizard Of Oz," where "you pull away the curtain and it's Professor Marvel -- it's not the Wizard of Oz."

"That's their problem," Rich said, referring to NBC, "[and] that's probably irreparable for Williams."

Williams came under fire in February after claiming that his helicopter was shot down while he'd been reporting in Iraq in 2003. He later admitted it was not true and that he'd "misremembered."

The controversy ignited a wave of fact-checking the narratives of fellow news anchors. Fox's Bill O'Reilly was quickly suspected of making similar mistakes, but according to Rich, the nature of O'Reilly's TV program and reputation have made his missteps more passable.

O'Reilly and Williams are "like apples and oranges," Rich said. "O'Reilly is an opinion guy. He's a commentator. It's more of a talk show in a way than a news show."

Watch more from Frank Rich's conversation with HuffPost Live here.

Sign up here for Live Today, HuffPost Live’s morning email that will let you know the newsmakers, celebrities and politicians joining us that day and give you the best clips from the day before!



Who Could Replace Brian Williams At NBC Nightly News?