04/13/2015 07:55 pm ET Updated Apr 14, 2015

Tennessee Suspends Executions Amid Legal Challenges To Lethal Injection, Electric Chair

The Tennessee Supreme Court has suspended executions of convicted murderers amid legal challenges contending that lethal injection and the electric chair are cruel and unusual punishments.

The state high court, in an order filed Friday, halted all executions and vacated execution dates for four inmates who had been scheduled to be put to death through early 2016.

"We're grateful that the Tennessee Supreme Court saw fit to lift these execution dates at least temporarily as the courts are proceeding with all this litigation," Stacy Rector, executive director of Tennesseans for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, told The Huffington Post by phone Monday.

The court may set new execution dates as the anti-death penalty litigation proceeds.

Inmates on Tennessee's death row have sued the state, alleging that the primary execution method of single-drug lethal injection and the backup execution method of electrocution are unconstitutional because they're cruel and unusual punishments.

The trial over Tennessee's use of the electric chair starts next month, and the trial over the lethal injection protocol is scheduled for July, the Tennesseean reports.

"Obviously for us, the lethal injections are troubling," Rector said. "But equally troubling is the whole system: The expense to taxpayers, the lingering effects on victim's families and the prospect of executing an innocent person."

In May 2014, Tennessee legalized the electric chair as a backup execution method to lethal injection. In the '90s, the U.S. Supreme Court was poised to examine the constitutionality of the electric chair after a Florida inmate's hair caught fire during an execution.

As death penalty states struggle to find lethal injection chemicals that have run low due to bans and distribution issues, and defend legal challenges to the legality of execution methods, states like Georgia have suspended scheduled executions, while states like Pennsylvania have imposed moratoriums.

Other states -- like Utah and Oklahoma -- have rushed legislation to approve backup methods of execution, should lethal injection become an unworkable option.

Rector said such actions are a "band-aid" to the systemic problems that she says plague the death penalty, and prove the system is "broke and dysfunctional."

"We are really seeing a lot of concern in our legislature with this issue -- particularly with risks to executing an innocent person, costs and the effects on victim's families," Rector said. The new execution methods, she said, will make the existing system even more costly and complex.

Since 2000, Tennessee has executed six inmates and exonerated three, Rector said. (One of those exonerated inmates accepted a deal to plead guilty to a lesser crime in exchange for freedom.)



Capital Punishment Methods