How Not to Build a Boat

I expressed my admiration for what he had accomplished, and he suggested what he had learned in the process of building a boat for past twenty years --
This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. If you need to flag this entry as abusive, send us an email.

There is always some progress, even when things are at their worst, because then you don't have to do over again all the negative things you've already done. -- Alberto Giacometti

Through an unlikely and unintended set of circumstances I met a fit and weathered man a few years my senior. While showing me around his goat farm, he referred in passing to his boat, and, intrigued, I asked him about it. He said he'd been building a 105' sloop for the past twenty years, and was still working at it. I said I wanted to have a look. Within an hour my son and I were trying to be of some use and trying not to get caught up in the lines. I expressed my admiration for what he had accomplished, and he suggested what he had learned in the process of building a boat for past twenty years -- "I know how not to build a boat."

I learned to make etchings pretty much on my own. I even tried things out on students in my classes and learned from their mistakes, which were of course my own mistakes. I learned lots of ways to do things wrong.

I wonder about the value of telling students they're making a mistake, even while they're making one. I used to tell students exactly how not to do something, and then they would decide to listen and do just what I told them not to do. So I stopped telling them and let them make their own mistakes. Mistakes are things you learn not to do again; you have no reason to even to think about them again. Mistakes in art generally have little consequence; no one gets harmed, except maybe some art supplies.

But avoiding mistakes doesn't create something beautiful or useful, let alone a 105' sloop.

2013-10-30-HowNottoBuild.jpg
Nick van Nes with Mass Transit 105 in the distance. Photograph by Brian D. Cohen

Popular in the Community

Close

What's Hot