05/13/2005 06:19 pm ET Updated May 25, 2011

I'd second Ze's critique. That there's no open comments tag in the post-footer only confirms the suspicions of those who already view the site as an "old media" attempt to take over a new platform. (Why those suspicions are unfounded I'll get into later.)

As for a "non-linear" format: I've already written here about the need for an elastic structure that can clearly organize multiple conversations and threads. Given the sheer range of voices and styles on this page, an elastic structure wouldn't solve everything -- but it would at least let some of us avoid Gutfeld"s posts.