POLITICS
07/19/2018 03:03 pm ET Updated Jul 20, 2018

New EPA Chief Faces First Major Lawsuit As States Challenge 'Super-Polluting' Trucks Rule

Yet another problem Andrew Wheeler is inheriting from former Administrator Scott Pruitt.
Andrew Wheeler, acting administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency, waits to speak to employees at the agency's head
Bloomberg via Getty Images
Andrew Wheeler, acting administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency, waits to speak to employees at the agency's headquarters in Washington on July 11.

WASHINGTON ― Sixteen state attorneys general sued the Environmental Protection Agency on Thursday over its decision to allow semitruck manufacturers to keep building some of their most polluting vehicles.

It’s the first major state challenge to land on the desk of new EPA chief Andrew Wheeler since he took charge of the agency earlier this month following the sudden resignation of Scott Pruitt.

The coalition filing the suit includes the attorneys general of California, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, New Mexico, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, and the District of Columbia, as well as the California Air Resources Board, the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency and the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection.

At issue is a 2016 Obama administration rule limiting sales of “glider trucks” ― new truck bodies and cabs with salvaged engines and chassis ― to 300 per manufacturer per year. Freight truck companies sell roughly 10,000 of these “super-polluting” trucks per year, as they’ve become known. During his last few hours at the EPA, Pruitt moved to delay enforcement of the rule in what was widely seen as his parting shot.

The EPA’s own November 2017 tests show a single glider truck emits 30 times as much nitrogen oxide and 60 times as much particulate matter as a modern truck. Without the rule, the trucks expected to be sold in the next year alone would release 13 times as much nitrogen oxide over the next decade as all the diesel cars Volkswagen sold with fraudulent emissions controls.

Last Friday, the same group of state officials sent a letter urging Wheeler to reverse the “unlawful rule suspension masquerading as an exercise of enforcement discretion.” On Tuesday, a trio of environmental groups ― the Sierra Club, the Environmental Defense Fund and the Center for Biological Diversity ― sued the EPA, calling for an emergency motion to block the decision. On Wednesday, a federal court handed them a victory, issuing a temporary stay on the rule delay.

Now, the states, which say delaying the rule causes their citizens “irreparable harm,” are piling on, asking the court to “promptly overturn the EPA’s order or halt the order’s effect until the court can rule on the merits of the lawsuit.”

Bob Riha Jr / Reuters

“As EPA Administrator, Scott Pruitt’s job was to act as our country’s chief environmental protector,” California Attorney General Xavier Becerra said in a statement. “At every turn ― even until the bitter end ― he failed to carry out this important duty and instead put the profits of major polluters above the health of our families.”

The legal fight over the glider rule marks the third controversy Wheeler has faced since becoming acting administrator on July 9. Last Friday, Democrats demanded that the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform issue a subpoena forcing the EPA to hand over documents related to Pruitt’s efforts to delay the release of public records. The call came in response to newly released congressional testimony revealing that EPA chief of staff Ryan Jackson appeared to be slow-walking Freedom of Information Act requests deemed “politically charged” or sensitive to political appointees.

Two days earlier, Wheeler named Henry Darwin, the EPA’s chief of operations, as acting deputy administrator, making him the agency’s new No. 2 official. The promotion attracted criticism after emails cited by ABC News showed Darwin helped his wife, Veronica Darwin, get a job at the agency as part of his salary negotiation for his previous position last year. Pruitt’s use of his office to obtain work for his wife, Marlyn Pruitt, became one of the final high-profile personal scandals that led to his departure.

“We are reviewing the decision,” the EPA said in a statement to HuffPost. 

This story was updated to include a comment from the EPA.

CONVERSATIONS