Randi Weingarten must be out of her damn mind!
The president of the second largest teachers union in the country, The American Federation of Teachers, is now writing op-eds with anti-union activists!?
Perhaps you remember him. He’s the corporate shill who infamously bragged on YouTube about tricking teachers unions into supporting an Illinois law that would have stripped educators of their right to strike while eliminating seniority and due process.
And why is she joining forces with a man who has dedicated his life to destroying the lives of the more than 1.5 million people she is supposed to represent!?
To fight school vouchers while pretending charter schools are a much better alternative.
No, I’m not kidding.
In the midst of an article that correctly outlines many of the problems with school vouchers, you’ll find this telling nugget:
We believe taxpayer money should support schools that are accountable to voters, open to all, nondenominational and transparent about students’ progress. Such schools — district and charter public schools — are part of what unites us as a country.
So once again we get the false distinction between charter and voucher schools.
Yet they ignore that BOTH are run privately without community input.
BOTH are not accountable to taxpayers.
BOTH are allowed to cherry pick the easiest students to educate and turn away those with special needs.
Yet Weingarten and her new best friend somehow think charters are worlds better than vouchers.
Wrong! They’re BOTH terrible.
Publicly funding privately run schools is nearly the same no matter whether you call them charter, private or parochial schools!
Yet we see Democratic partisans trying desperately to distinguish their cash cow charter schools from the extremely similar golden geese of voucher schools.
It’s a trick. Republicans champion privatized education in all of its forms. Democrats pretend to be discerning by boosting only charter schools.
But there’s really very little difference between these two positions. In each case, these partisan hacks are defending privatization against any and all forms of public education.
Weingarten apparently is even willing to throw the majority of her constituents under the bus to do so!
Charter schools are a failed social experiment. The majority have become merely parasites on traditional public school districts sucking out much needed funding without putting anything of value back.
They result in larger class sizes, a narrowing of the curriculum and more layoffs for the very teachers Weingarten is supposed to represent.
In the rare occasions when charters actually provide good educational value, the law explicitly allows them to change for the worse at any time. The problem isn’t a few bad apples. It’s the concept of charter schools, themselves.
You can’t have a separate level of school competing with its community district and expect the two not to end up harming each other. You can’t allow one school to operate in the dark without hardly any transparency and expect operators not to take personal advantage of it. You can’t allow one school to choose its students without expecting to drastically segregate the community’s children.
Yet here we have Weingarten joining hands with the devil signing a Faustian bargain with the blood of every member of the American Federation of Teachers.
Yes, school vouchers are a bad idea. They violate the separation of church and state. But other than that, they’re pretty much the same as charter schools. If you agree to defend the one while attacking the other, you’re just fighting about what to name the privatized school that will eventually overtake the public ones.
Weingarten should know that.
But this isn’t the first time recently that she’s agreed to hob knob with those salivating over the destruction of her own chosen profession.
Just last month, she went on a field trip to a public school with Betsy DeVos, our Anti-Education Education Secretary.
As parent and teacher activists were physically barring DeVos from entering some public schools, Weingarten was giving her a guided tour!
Some will say that we need to educate DeVos, a Republican mega-donor with next to zero experience of public education and a history of spending billions to destroy public schools. So how did it work out?
DeVos said the school was nice but could benefit from more privatization.
Thanks anyway, Randi.
You can’t make friends with the corporate education reformers.
This was one of the major weaknesses of Democratic Presidential candidate Hillary Clinton. She tried to walk this same divide praising “high quality” charter schools while criticizing those that exploit the system.
In both cases, they’re ignoring the fact that the system was designed EXPLICITLY TO BE EXPLOITED – by charter schools.
They aren’t listening to their constituents.
They have both gone rogue. They are playing politics on our dime without giving proper consideration to what’s in our benefit.
Teachers don’t want their national union representatives playing patty cake with those out to destroy us. We want action in the streets! We want activists and resisters, not diplomats and politicians.
It’s time Randi and Lily stepped aside for union leaders who understand what our schools, our students and our profession really needs.
This was originally published on my Blog.