09/26/2013 09:06 am ET Updated Nov 26, 2013

Lessons From Elizabeth Gilbert (That Don't Involve Eating, Praying, or Loving)

Originally posted on the blog School of Smock:

I'll admit it: "Eat, Pray, Love" is not one of my favorite books. That's an understatement. It's not even in the top 1000. Actually, it annoyed me so much in parts that I skipped long sections of it. But I adore Elizabeth Gilbert and couldn't wait to read a profile of her by Steve Almond, another one of my favorite writers, in this week's New York Times Magazine.

How can you be an admirer of Elizabeth Gilbert and not a fan of "Eat, Pray, Love"? I mean, really, what else has she done? It's simple: Elizabeth Gilbert is a writer's writer. She is a master craftswoman. She's versatile and daring.

As a journalist, a biographer, short story writer, or an essayist, she can write vividly and movingly about anything from cowboys and pioneer life to Hank Williams III. (My personal favorite? Her piece about being a waitress at the Coyote Ugly bar that later inspired a movie...)

Already a fan, in 2006 I was excited to read her memoir about searching for meaning, identity, and joy across the world. Like the rest of female America, a friend passed the book onto me. I had recently gone through my own period of sadness, loss and confusion after a horrific breakup and the death of my father. I could relate to sitting and sobbing on the bathroom floor, devoid of hope and desperate for answers and meaning (for me, one of the most powerful scenes in the book).

Yet after enjoying the section of "Eat, Pray, Love" about her stay in Italy, somewhere in India, she lost me as a reader. I started to find her story self-indulgent and sort of boring. First of all, I'm not a New Age-type of person. When faced with crisis, I do not meditate or do yoga. But I'll leave my complaints about "Eat, Pray, Love" (and the movie, her Oprah stuff, etc.) for now. (One critic perfectly states my ambivalence about the book: "['Eat, Pray, Love'] is the worst in Western fetishization of Eastern thought and culture, assured in its answers to existential dilemmas that have confounded intellects greater than hers. You may be a well-off white woman, but if you are depressed, the answer can be found in the East, where the poor brown people are sages.")

But we all get through losing our way in life and find a path toward resilience in different ways. I didn't fault Elizabeth herself for the media creation of her as a self-help guru that developed over the next years. And I loved her follow-up to "Eat, Pray, Love," "Committed: A Love Story." I had recently married too (at age 35) and had been struggling with my own thoughts about independence, compatibility, and the daily negotiations of marriage.

Yet even if you find no connection to Elizabeth's writings about her journeys of self-discovery, as writers of all types (students, bloggers, journalists, scholars, fiction writers), Elizabeth can teach us important lessons.

1. Write like you have nothing to lose. Be bold, be unexpected, and challenge your readers and yourself.

2. Don't confine yourself to one genre when you're passionate about many. Elizabeth has written and spoken about her dislike for the term "chick-lit." As a respected and award-winning journalist and literary novelist, she was baffled when she wrote about her own search for meaning and love but was suddenly relegated to the category of soft, light, and fluffy "women's writing." In her soon-to-be-published book The Signature of All Things: A Novel, she is going back to her literary fiction roots with a "serious" epic of historical fiction. Elizabeth refuses to be defined by literary categories or by readers' and critics' expectations of her work.

3. Don't be afraid of being happy and content in your personal life. Strive for it in any way you can. Artists of all types make the mistake, according to Elizabeth, of believing that true creative genius only arises from suffering and misery. Gilbert believes that the balance and satisfaction that she found in her own personal life actually allows her to be a better writer. She does not romanticize the pain and sorrow that she has experienced and has no desire to return to it for the sake of art.

4. Find a community who loves you and respects you for who you are as a person and a writer. Gilbert surrounds herself with like-minded and loyal friends. She has long friendships and finds self-imposed seclusion to be harmful to her own creative processes. Her friends are her coaches, her critics, her family, and her greatest admirers.

5. Don't use an "artistic temperament" as a crutch. Yes, writers and artists can be sensitive, passionate, imaginative, emotional, and turn inward. But passion and creativity will only get you so far. Hard work is the key to success on your own terms. You need to learn discipline and develop a strong work ethic. Art of all kinds is ultimately most about work -- hard, difficult work.

Her next book, coming out on October 1, is called "The Signature of All Things: A Novel." It's an epic story set in cities across the globe, telling the tale of the Whittaker family during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. First, there is Henry Whittaker, who becomes the richest man in Philadelphia through the South American quinine trade. The book's heroine is his daughter, Alma, who becomes a botanist and researcher. It's about passion, science, evolution and the tension between reason and the divine.

Do you plan on reading her new novel? What did you think of "Eat, Pray, Love"? Are you a fan of Elizabeth Gilbert?