For yet a third time, a federal judge has ordered the NYPD to release 2,000 pages of secret documents, showing how it spied on groups planning legal protests at the 2004 Republican National Convention at Madison Square Garden.
District Judge Richard Sullivan last week affirmed a 2008 order by Federal Magistrate James Francis IV that the NYPD's Intelligence Division turn over the documents.
But will Police Commissioner Ray Kelly and his newly appointed, $165,000 special council Katherine Ann Lemire, formerly of the U.S. Attorney's office, find another legal dodge to avoid doing so?
In short, will Kelly and Deputy Commissioner for Intelligence David Cohen abandon their "secret documents defense" and therefore lose their case against the protesters so that New Yorkers will never see those secret files?
In court papers known as the "Cohen Declaration," Cohen had argued that releasing even redacted secret documents would compromise the department and harm the fight against terrorism.
A more cynical interpretation is that releasing the documents would embarrass him and Kelly, revealing that the Intelligence Division's spying might not only have been inept and misguided but illegal.
In an apparent last minute decision on the eve of discovery on Dec. 12, 2006, after two years of litigation, the police department had cited this spying to justify the arrests of 1,806 protesters at the RNC.
The New York Civil Liberties Union had questioned whether many of those protestors had been illegally detained.
That decision, by police department and city lawyers, led to making public the Intelligence Division's secret spying. Until then, no one outside the NYPD knew of it.
The department maintained that the protesters' arrests and detentions stemmed from what Intelligence Division detectives had learned from their spying. But when the NYCLU asked exactly what Intel had learned and sought to see the documents, Kelly and Cohen refused to reveal them.
The spying became public knowledge in March, 2007, when Jim Dwyer of the New York Times revealed that Intel detectives traveled to cities across the country, to Canada and to Europe to secretly monitor people who planned to protest at the RNC.
"In hundreds of reports stamped 'N.Y.P.D. Secret,' the Intelligence Division chronicled the views and plans of people who had no apparent intention of breaking the law, the records show," the Times reported
Now let's step back and examine how all this might have came about.
This apparent abuse of power began with Commissioner Kelly's response to the horror of the 9/11 attacks when he expanded the department's long dormant Intelligence Division under Cohen, a 35-year veteran of the CIA, an agency bound by no known laws.
Noting that the FBI had failed to protect the city before 9/11, Kelly stated in 2002, "We feel we have to protect ourselves."
Thus began Kelly's and Cohen's revamped Intelligence Division, which created, in the words of a number of law enforcement officials, a mini-CIA - but without safeguards to ensure it didn't break the law and become, in the words of a terrorism expert with whom the NYPD has consulted, "a rogue entity."
In Feb., 2003, after police arrested 274 people who demonstrated against the Iraq war, Intelligence Division detectives questioned the protesters in their cells, demanding to know the names of their friends and political affiliations, what schools they had attended, what organizations they belonged to, what they thought of Israel and Palestine and where they had been on 9/11.
Federal judge Charles Haight reprimanded Kelly, who promised that such questioning would end.
In the fall of 2003, Kelly and Cohen began sending Intel detectives on secret forays out-of-state, where the NYPD lacks jurisdiction, without informing the FBI or local authorities.
On the Jersey shore, as this column has reported, Intel detectives conducted a sting of scuba shops before local authorities asked them to leave New Jersey.
In the town of Carlisle, in Western Pennsylvania, they investigated the theft of explosives before the local police chief asked them to return to New York.
In Boston, Intel detectives infiltrated a church meeting of a protest group called the Black Tea Society, and then were nearly arrested for speeding after they initially refused to identify themselves to Mass. state police.
Meanwhile, Kelly and Cohen based Intelligence Division detectives overseas to rival the FBI. Perhaps their most notable achievement was succeeding in being faster than the Bureau to interview the Spanish National Police after the 2004 Madrid train bombing.
At Cohen's direction in the fall of 2007, Intel detectives delayed the Iranian delegation to the United Nations at Kennedy airport for 40 minutes by searching them for weapons - violating diplomatic protocol and disregarding protests from officials of the State Department, Secret Service and the Port Authority police.
In the fall of 2008, Kelly complained to Attorney General Michael Mukasey that the federal government needlessly delayed the NYPD's eavesdropping applications because of legal concerns. Mukasey responded that Kelly was acting "contrary to the law."
Last September, the Intelligence Division disrupted an FBI investigation into perhaps the most serious terrorism threat to New Yorkers since 9/11. Apparently without informing the Bureau, which had been tracking terrorism suspect Najibullah Zazi, Intel detectives showed his photo to one of their informants, a Queens imam, who tipped off Zazi. The Bureau was forced to arrest Zazi and the imam before learning the extent of the plot.
Back in 2008, the Times also reported that the city had spent $8.2 million in settlement costs and legal fees growing out of Intel's RNC spying. Whether or not the police department releases the secret spying documents or settles with the protesters, that cost is going to grow.
THE MARQUES DOCTRINE. "I see run-ins with public information people as part of the job," Daily News Managing Editor Stuart Marques wrote in an email message, explaining why the News chose not to report that a sergeant in the Public Information office threatened and cursed its own reporter, Wil Cruz, for simply trying to do his job.
"As in this case," Marques continued, "I call the guy's boss to complain and see if it can be worked out. I then tell the reporter to try to work it out with the p.r. person. If they can't, I'll call again and also will let the editor-in-chief know about it."
"The guy's boss," as Marques put it, was Deputy Commissioner Paul Browne. In another email, Marques said he "communicated my anger" to Browne, and that Browne "apologized and said it wouldn't happen again."
O.K., Stu, If that's all true, why hasn't Browne and/or the sergeant apologized to Cruz?
FOUND in Woodbridge, Virginia: John Picciano, the wandering lamster and chief of staff for New York's about-to-be-imprisoned 40th police commissioner, Bernard Bailey Kerik. Picciano's job down south: private security. Living arraignments: renting a private house from a friend of his boss but about to be evicted after resigning unexpectedly a month or so ago. Prospects: excellent. Pitch does have a way about him. Former friends he's in touch with: Well, when one of them calls, he leaves the name, "Hector Santiago," who Kerik's former partner and bodyguard.
And speaking of Kerik, did you catch the pictures he recently posted on Facebook, showing him slimmed-down and clean-shaven? His once-massive shoulders appear to have mysteriously shrunk to normal size.